Participatory evaluation

Framing participatory evaluation. This 1998 paper by J. Bradley Cousins and Elizabeth Whitmore presents two main streams of participatory evaluation, practical participatory evaluation and transformative participatory evaluation, and compares them with regard to a number of dimensions such as control, level, and range of participation.

Developmental evaluation. Developmental Evaluation (DE) is an evaluation approach that can assist social innovators develop social change initiatives in complex or uncertain environments. DE originators liken their approach to the role of research & development in the private sector product development process because it facilitates real-time ...Participatory evaluation (PE) is a method of inquiry in the family of participatory and action research. These traditions in research and evaluation grew out of conflicts and contradictions about how knowledge is created and used. There are at least three major traditions in participatory research and evaluation, all of which are concerned with ..."The focus of this participatory process evaluation is to gauge the activities being implemented for the underserved and marginalized groups in Nevada." To conduct this evaluation, Sharma, professor and chair of the social and behavioral health department in the School of Public Health, received a Health Disparity Grant in July 2021 from ...KEY WORDS: evaluation, participatory research, youth development, youth engagement Efforts to involve young people as research part-ners build on well-established participatory research methods and create opportunities both for promoting youth development (YD) and for improving the sci-entific study of issues affecting young people's lives.Advocacy Evaluation Training Pack.3 Another popular approach is known as participatory program evaluation. This approach involves external stakeholders who monitor and evaluate your activities, rather than merely relying solely on internal M&E. A number of resources discuss participatory M&E, and these are listed in the Additional Resources ...participatory evaluation in your own research and work as adult educator. while in Section 9.3 and Section 9.4 it describes the historical context and process of participatory evaluation. In Section 9.4 you will find a detailed description of the tools of participatory monitoring and evaluation. Section 9.5 discusses participatory evaluation tools.A participatory learning approach, applied at each stage of a community development project, is crucial to reaching the level of stakeholder involvement needed for lasting, positive change. The use of participatory survey and planning methods in the development process encourages community ownership of projects, allows for information toParticipatory Approaches to Evaluation Lori Bakken, MS, PhD Professor, School of Human Ecology, Civil Society and Community Studies Evaluation Specialist, Division of …

Evaluation Plan, 2) Objectives and Indicators, 3) Monitoring, 4) Evaluation, and 5) Research Design. The ... and participatory methods required to implement the study design Methods •Calculate sampling frame and size based on participant groups Sampling •Determine how the data will be cleaned, stored, and analysed Data ManagementThe definitive guide to CBPR concepts and practice, updated and expanded Community-Based Participatory Research for Health: Advancing Health and Social Equity provides a comprehensive reference for this rapidly growing field in participatory and community-engaged research. Hailed as effective by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, CBPR and CEnR represent the link between ...Participatory evaluation of a quality improvement collaborative Patient Safety Collaboratives In 2014, NHS England commissioned 15 Patient Safety Collaboratives hosted by Academic Health Science Networks to deliver safety improvement in response to Professor Don Berwick's report A Promise to Learn—aParticipatory monitoring and evaluation for quality programs in higher education: What is the way fo... International Journal of Educational Administration and Policy Studies. PDF | On Dec 15 ...The Toolkit on Gender Sensitive Participatory Evaluation Methods draws on the rich experience of the use of participatory tools within an evaluation context, and engenders the same.PRA is an assessment and learning process that empowers farmers to create the information base they need for participatory planning and action. Outsiders contribute facilitation skills and external information and opinions. Many different tools have been developed for use in PRA. There are four main classes: tools used in group and team ...Download Table | Scoring and ranking of Solanum accessions. from publication: Participatory characterization and evaluation of some African leafy vegetables in Lari, Kiambu West District, Central ...

research methods: RRA (Rapid Rural Appraisal) and PRA (Participatory Rural Appraisal). As noted in the sections that follow, these methods are participatory and qualitative and are especially valuable in gathering information that will provide insights about people and the communities in which they live. These insights will, in turn, enableAdvantages of doing participatory evaluation. Identify locally relevant evaluation questions. Improve accuracy and relevance of reports. Establish and explain causality. Improve program performance. Empower participants. Build capacity. Develop leaders and build teams. Sustain organizational learning and growth.The participatory evaluation process. How participatory evaluation works, its goals, the roles people may play in the process, what to expect. Meeting skills. Following discussion, listening skills, handling disagreement or conflict, contributing and responding appropriately, general ground rules and etiquette, etc. Interviewing. Putting people ...The definitive guide to CBPR concepts and practice, updated and expanded Community-Based Participatory Research for Health: Advancing Health and Social Equity provides a comprehensive reference for this rapidly growing field in participatory and community-engaged research. Hailed as effective by the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, CBPR and CEnR represent the link between ...

Benefits of supervisor training.

Conclusions: This research provides support for the importance of an early-stage participatory evaluation of beneficiaries' perceptions of newly initiated health programmes. Our results support how evaluations conducted in the early phases of programme implementation can provide valuable, timely feedback as well as yield recommendations for ...Participatory research is a systematic inquiry whereby academics conduct joint research with nonacademic partners affected by the issue being studied, ... Ensuring transparency and rigor of the approach remains crucial as it lays the groundwork for critical evaluation of this strategy. The 12 steps we propose here constitute a major milestone ...Abstract. Participatory evaluation (PE) turns out to be a variably used and ill-defined approach to evaluation that, juxtaposed to more conventional forms and approaches, has generated much controversy in educational and social and human services evaluation. Despite a relatively wide array of evaluation and evaluation-related activities ...Participatory evaluation is presented as an extension of the stakeholder-based model with a focus on enhancing evaluation utilization through primary users' increased depth and range of participation in the applied research process. The approach is briefly described and then justified from theoretical and empirical bases. The literature on organizational learning provides theoretical support ...Thus, our evaluation framework provides a practical way of assessing SDG 11.3.2 and 16.7.2 achievement in a particular public participation practice. The core findings of this study show that the participatory process of the village Musrenbang faces substantial challenges in practice to match with the SDG goals. All four evaluation themes of ...

Abstract. Community-based participatory research (CBPR) has been widely used in public health research in the last decade as an approach to develop culturally centered interventions and collaborative research processes in which communities are directly involved in the construction and implementation of these interventions and in other application of findings.Youth participatory research has roots in several related fields including action research, community development, empowerment evaluation, and positive YD. 4,18 It utilizes an ecological-developmental framework, in which human development is optimized when "maximum support and maximum challenge" offer opportunities to engage in increasingly ...Moving Participatory Evaluation from Theory to Practice. The study participants emphasized that they brought youth-centered and strength-based approaches with them to the CPAR Institute, stressing the role of sports, the arts, culture, families, and civic engagement. However, only two of the five organizations had previously used participatory ...Health & Social Care in the Community will continue to undergo a rigorous peer review process ensuring that quality remains high. Manuscripts published after January 1, 2023 are published as open access articles, making them immediately free to read, download and share. Authors or their funder will be required to pay an Article Publication ...Presented in this paper is a generalizable program planning model that includes participants in eight planning components. Some of the pitfalls of participatory work as well as examples of how participatory planning could be used in various contexts are provided. Program evaluation. 1. Introduction.evaluation, consider the needs of and get input from your evaluation stakeholders. The central evaluation questions and evaluation purpose (i.e., what are you trying to learn and why?) should drive both the way that information is collected and how it is shared. Who cares about the evaluation results or are impacted by the results?Conventional and Participatory Evaluation Evaluation can broadly be viewed as being participatory and conventional. A participatory approach is a broad concept focusing on the involvement of primary and other stakeholders in an undertaking such as program planning, design implementation, monitoring, and evaluation.Evaluation Methods. There are many different methods and processes that can be used in monitoring and evaluation (M&E). Use the search field and filtering on this page to find the methods you are interested in or browse our extensive list. If you'd like help finding methods that can be used for specific tasks in evaluation (like collecting data ...Participatory evaluation is increasingly being recognized as an effective approach to gathering valid, culturally relevant data across diverse fields . In one stream of this approach—practical participatory evaluation—program recipients, who often lack a voice in program and policy decisions, can influence program decision making [1, 14].Nov 3, 2021 · Participatory evaluation is an approach that involves the stakeholders of a programme or policy in the evaluation process. This involvement can occur at any stage of the evaluation process, from the evaluation design to the data collection and analysis and the reporting of the study.

BetterEvaluation aims to produce significant improvements in evaluation through its two integrated core elements: a knowledge platform (betterevaluation.org) research and innovation projects. Through these integrated activities, we co-create, share and support use of knowledge about doing, managing and using evaluation better.

Yet compared to evaluation and policy research, little has been written about how to plan programs as well as how participants can be part of the process. ... 2016), and participatory evaluation methods (Nichols, 2002). Show abstract. Indigenous Peoples living in rural and remote regions of Canada, the United States, and Australia experience ...Conceptualizing the dimensions of participatory evaluation is a first step toward increasing our understanding of PE, enhancing process use, and developing ways to enhance participation in PE and ...evaluation models; such as the Theory-based evaluation, Participatory evaluation and Growth mixture evaluation. The multi-component of the methodology for collecting data requires a triangulated mixed-method evaluation plan focusing on process, impact and outcomes using both qualitative and quantitative assessments. The informationAs a manager, it’s a fundamental responsibility to evaluate employee performance at work. While it seems like giving performance reviews would be reasonably simple, it’s often more challenging than managers expect.Participatory methods can be a great asset for project evaluation, as they can improve the quality, relevance, and usefulness of the evaluation data and outcomes. Nevertheless, they also present ...Abstract. Evaluation occurs within a specific context and is influenced by the economic, political, historical, and social forces that shape that context. The culture of evaluation is thus very much embedded in the culture of accountability that currently prevails in public sector institutions, policies, and program.ParEvo is a method of developing alternative past histories or future scenarios using a participatory evolutionary process (hence ParEvo). This involves the re-iteration of variation, selection and reproduction, i.e. the evolutionary algorithm (Campbell, 1960; Dennett, 1996:48-60).The process is designed to be used by multiple people to produce a collective good - a set of storylines.What is participatory evaluation? ___Participatory evaluation is an evaluation that involves all the stakeholders in a project - those directly affected by it or by carrying it out - in every phase of evaluating it, and in applying the results of that evaluation to the improvement of the workSection 1. A Framework for Program Evaluation: A Gateway to Tools; Section 2. Community-based Participatory Research; Section 3. Understanding Community Leadership, Evaluators, and Funders: What Are Their Interests? Section 4. Choosing Evaluators; Section 5. Developing an Evaluation Plan; Section 6. Participatory Evaluation

Linguistics constituency tests.

Kay flock with braids.

Participatory evaluation of a quality improvement collaborative Patient Safety Collaboratives In 2014, NHS England commissioned 15 Patient Safety Collaboratives hosted by Academic Health Science Networks to deliver safety improvement in response to Professor Don Berwick's report A Promise to Learn—aFunctions of Participatory Evaluation Participatory evaluation thus serves four key functions, some of which concern the stakeholders and beneficiaries while others relate to the funding agencies. It helps to build the capacity of stakeholders to reflect, analyse and take?action. While such analysis should occur throughout the life of a project,Simon Hearn. Outcome mapping (OM) is a methodology for planning, monitoring and evaluating development initiatives in order to bring about sustainable social change. As the name suggests, its niche is understanding outcomes; the so-called ‘missing-middle’ or ‘black box’ of results that emerge downstream from the initiative’s ...BetterEvaluation aims to produce significant improvements in evaluation through its two integrated core elements: a knowledge platform (betterevaluation.org) research and innovation projects. Through these integrated activities, we co-create, share and support use of knowledge about doing, managing and using evaluation better.Heron, a pioneer in the development of participatory methods in the social sciences, describes the theory and practice of the method in his 1996 book, Co-operative Inquiry: research into the human condition. It involves a group working through a structured, four-stage cycle of action and reflection, through which group members move towards ...Framing participatory evaluation in Understanding and practicing participatory evaluation. In E. Whitemore (Ed.), New directions for evaluation (Vol. 80, pp. 5-23). San Francisco: Jossey-Bass. Google Scholar. de Lancer Julnes, P., & Holzer, M. (2001). Promoting the utilization of performance measures in public organizations: An empirical study ...Supportingnationalcapacitydevelopmentforpovertyreductionandtheattainmentof theMillenniumDevelopmentGoalsliesattheveryheartofUNDP’smandate.ThatGFC recently completed a participatory evaluation for a four-year initiative funded by Dubai Cares, a global philanthropic organization based in the United Arab Emirates, to advance the rights and opportunities of adolescent girls in Central America. The learning review—as GFC calls evaluations to put the emphasis on learning—was a ...Transformative Evaluation, an approach specifically designed for youth and community work, is presented. Part 3 focuses on the 'doing' of participatory evaluation and offers guidance to those new to participatory evaluation in youth and community work and a helpful check for those already engaging. It provides valuable information on ...Participatory M&E is about engaging different stakeholders, especially targeted beneficiaries, in monitoring and evaluation processes. It is done to generate better M&E information and/or to empower stakeholders . It is facilitated through two main approaches. The first is a set of tools and methods used to enableThe American Evaluation Association is devoted to the application and exploration of program evaluation, personnel evaluation, technology, and many other forms of evaluation. We strive to provide an inclusive and diverse environment where evaluators can learn and connect regardless of experience in the field.Framing participatory evaluation. This 1998 paper by J. Bradley Cousins and Elizabeth Whitmore presents two main streams of participatory evaluation, practical participatory evaluation and transformative participatory evaluation, and compares them with regard to a number of dimensions such as control, level, and range of participation. ….

There are so many different aspects of participatory grant making that you could measure; the impact of the grants, the relationship between funder and communities, the skills of those involved in the process to name just a few. So the question of how to evaluate PGM can't be solved with a simple framework that can be applied across the board ...PARTICIPATORY RESEARCH 91 P ARTICIPATORY RESEARCH 8 Unit 8 will familiarizes you with the concepts and issues of participatory research and evaluation. In Section 8.2 you will get an exposure to a critique of the conventional research paradigm. To view participatory research as an alternative approach to conventional research, in Section 8.3 ...Participatory approaches emphasize stakeholder involvement (program staff and beneficiaries, among others) in all or most of the design, implementation, and reporting stages of an evaluation. Participatory evaluation is often motivated by the idea that actively involving stakeholders (including those affected by the program) in the evaluation ...In line with this research approach a participatory approach was adopted, conscious of the fact that learning happens during an evaluation process and not only from an evaluation report [13]. A ...Participatory approaches to evaluation lie at the core of this study to explore how we can encourage a more formative culture of evaluation in tourism. The EU-Interreg programme in which “Experience” operates is an interregional cooperation programme which strives to reduce disparities in levels of development, growth, and quality of life ...The book is an invaluable supplementary text for program evaluation courses where students’ projects are focused on more collaborative and participatory approaches, and it is an essential resource for practicing evaluators and those who commission program evaluations. Available Formats. ISBN: 9781544344645. Paperback.In the fast-paced and ever-evolving healthcare industry, it is crucial for healthcare organizations to have an effective system in place to evaluate the performance of their nursing staff.Participatory evaluation for community actions provides a viable alternative due to the general lack of evaluation culture in community organisations. It is a methodological strategy that involves all relevant voices in evaluation decision-making rather than only professionals. We approach this type of evaluation using social pedagogy.Participatory democracy was a notable feature of the Occupy movement in 2011. "Occupy camps" around the world made decisions based on the outcome of working groups where every protester had a say. These decisions were then aggregated by general assemblies. This process combined equality, mass participation, and deliberation. EvaluationParticipatory evaluation, a dimension of participatory development embodying many of the same concepts, involves the stakeholders and beneficiaries of a programme or project in the collective examination and assessment of that programme or project. It is people centred: project stakeholders and beneficiaries are the key actors of the evaluation ... Participatory evaluation, A sports physical is an examination. Most schools, camps and organizations require a sports physical before your child can participate in sports and other physical activities. Healthcare providers also call this exam a pre-participation physical evaluation (PPE). During a sports physical, your healthcare provider examines your child., Phase One – Participatory Communication Assessment (PCA): Issues are researched and analysed through exploratory two-way communication. For these tasks to be successful, it is necessary to establish an open or common space where key stakeholders can interact freely with each other. Phase Two – (Participatory) Communication Strategy Design ..., Participatory evaluation relies on the principle of active participation by major stakeholders, including the least organised groups, as being fundamental to good evaluation practice. This process ..., Generally, documentation of participatory evaluation of community level primary health programs is lacking or inadequate . We interpret that both participation of women and participation of health committees in participatory evaluation are towards the mobilization end of the community participation spectrum., Participatory evaluation offers a framework for engaging local stakeholders in each stage of the evaluation process, from deciding to evaluate and selecting priority questions to validating and utilizing evaluation findings. This note offers practical guidance and examples to help USAID and its evaluation partners design and carry out ..., Participatory evaluation: Going beyond the rhetoric Although 'empowerment' is a prominent value in the field of international development, attempts to monitor and measure it have largely relied on indicators determined by external people for external use. These approaches assumed that people's own assessments would be too simple, An annuity can be a useful long-term investment, especially for retirement. To buy an annuity contract, you give an insurance or investment company a large lump-sum payment. In exchange, the company invests your money and gives you monthly ..., The participatory evaluation process. How participatory evaluation works, its goals, the roles people may play in the process, what to expect. Meeting skills. Following discussion, listening skills, handling disagreement or conflict, contributing and responding appropriately, general ground rules and etiquette, etc. Interviewing. Putting people ..., participatory evaluation are also explored. Two participatory evaluation case examples are presented in Chap-ters 6 and 7. Chapter 6 describes the use of a participatory evaluation approach to evaluate a community health improvement initiative, focus - ing on heart disease and Type 2 diabetes. There are over 1.5 million heart attacks each year., GFC recently completed a participatory evaluation for a four-year initiative funded by Dubai Cares, a global philanthropic organization based in the United Arab Emirates, to advance the rights and opportunities of adolescent girls in Central America. The learning review—as GFC calls evaluations to put the emphasis on learning—was a ..., Two principal strands of participatory evaluation have been defined: (1) practical participatory evaluation that seeks to foster the use of evaluation for decision making; and (2) transformative participatory evaluation that seeks to empower participants and mobilize social change (Cousins and Whitmore, 1998). Why conduct participatory evaluation?, Employee self-evaluations are an important tool for both employees and employers. They provide an opportunity for employees to reflect on their own performance, set goals, and identify areas for improvement., Participatory design is an approach to design strategy that brings customers into the heart of the design process. Also known as “co-creation”, “co-design”, or “cooperative design”, it emcompasses techniques useful to both initial discovery and subsequent ideation phases of a project, where the end-users of a product, service, or ..., by participatory evaluation. In this case, a standard model may be more effective. The participatory model provides an opportunity for critical self-assessment, which can be used to improve the program. It is the level of commitment to self-assessment and program improvement, therefore, that determines the success of the evaluation., BOX 6-1 Key Definitions. Loneliness: the perception of social isolation or the subjective feeling of being lonely. Mediators: also known as mechanisms or pathways; the factors that help explain how social isolation or loneliness affects health outcomes. Moderators: the factors that can influence the magnitude or direction of the effect of social isolation or …, A transformative approach to assessment and evaluation centering family, student and educator voices. Transformative Assessment. The Participatory Evaluation ..., Download. Full Document [PDF – 2.6 MB] This Chapter [PDF – 998 KB] In addition to the concepts just summarized, the literature provides models and frameworks for understanding health promotion and health research that can be helpful in the practice of community engagement. We cover a number of those here., Funders ceding power over grant decisions is relevant now more than ever given the momentum of movements for justice. At Ford, we are in the beginning stages of exploring this model. In 2015, our former colleague Susie Jolly engaged with the topic in our China office. In 2017, to determine the efficacy of participatory grantmaking for an ..., Evaluation Methods. There are many different methods and processes that can be used in monitoring and evaluation (M&E). Use the search field and filtering on this page to find the methods you are interested in or browse our extensive list. If you'd like help finding methods that can be used for specific tasks in evaluation (like collecting data ..., Phase One – Participatory Communication Assessment (PCA): Issues are researched and analysed through exploratory two-way communication. For these tasks to be successful, it is necessary to establish an open or common space where key stakeholders can interact freely with each other. Phase Two – (Participatory) Communication Strategy Design ..., Participatory evaluation (PE) is a method of inquiry in the family of participatory and action research. These traditions in research and evaluation grew out of conflicts and contradictions about how knowledge is created and used., Using a participatory evaluation approach, we recently evaluated the partnerships' priorities for cancer education and outreach; perspectives on the partnerships' adherence to CBPR principles; and suggestions for sustaining TBCCN and its efforts. The purpose of this paper is to describe implementation and outcomes of this participatory ..., Conventional and Participatory Evaluation Evaluation can broadly be viewed as being participatory and conventional. A participatory approach is a broad concept focusing on the involvement of primary and other stakeholders in an undertaking such as program planning, design implementation, monitoring, and evaluation., Over the past couple of decades, members of the American Evaluation Association’s (AEA) Collaborative, Participatory, and Empowerment Evaluation Topical Interest Group (CPE-TIG) have labored to build a strong theoretical and empirical foundation of stakeholder involvement approaches in evaluation., Participatory evaluation has been developed collectively in popular education as a tool to empower people. It allows them to assess educational development projects from their own perspective in ..., As already described in previous work [], after their validation, the questionnaires have been proposed online to the members of the three main categories of actors of the educational processes—students, teachers, parents—to realize a participatory evaluation in 12 high schools.In five cases, the evaluation has been …, Evaluation Plan, 2) Objectives and Indicators, 3) Monitoring, 4) Evaluation, and 5) Research Design. The ... and participatory methods required to implement the study design Methods •Calculate sampling frame and size based on participant groups Sampling •Determine how the data will be cleaned, stored, and analysed Data Management, By practicing Youth Participatory Evaluation (YPE), evaluation is no longer just a task on their to-do list, it is a way for youth and adults to collaboratively assess and guide the program. The Youth Leadership Initiative has practiced YPE for almost five years. They believe in YPE because they've witnessed its benefits for youth, adults ..., It also showed the lack of local community participation in needs assessment, planning, implementation, monitoring, and evaluation tasks. According to Mubita et al. [39], participation can also ..., It draws on the available literature, including our own participatory evaluation of a project intended to increase youth participation in organizational development and community change. Get full access to this article. View all access and purchase options for this article., by ensuring that appropriate evaluation questions are identified and that evaluation results will be used to make a difference. Stakeholders are much more likely to support an evaluation and act on results and recommendations if they are involved throughout the evaluation process. Without stakeholder support, an evaluation may be ignored., The effort was led by a worker-based union-sponsored participatory evaluation team in partnership with a university researcher. Visual depiction of hazardous tasks and exposures focused primarily on improper or unsafe equipment, awkward postures, lifting hazards, and electrical hazards. The process of taking and presenting pictures created an ..., Abstract. Participatory evaluation is presented as an extension of the stakeholder-based model with a focus on enhancing evaluation utilization through primary users' increased depth and range of participation in the applied research process. The approach is briefly described and then justified from theoretical and empirical bases.